Initial Thoughts on Paul and the Gift by John Barclay

"Fourth, the New Perspective on Paul (NPP). I'll be brief here because I've only thus far read the introductory and concluding statements on Barclay's interaction with the NPP. Here's what he says to expect: E.P. Sanders and other advocates of the NPP argue that Judaism in Paul's day was a religion of grace. Barclay responds by arguing that "Grace is everywhere in Second Temple Judaism but not everywhere the same" (6). His point is that the NPP has given us a picture of Judaism that is insufficiently diverse. Paul was one voice in the middle of a debate on the nature of grace. Sanders made the mistake of reading different attitudes toward grace onto the Pauline texts without considering the extent to which Paul and his contemporaries might agree that God acts graciously toward his covenant people even though they disagree on the particulars of that grace. If this argument turns out to be successful, it will be a big problem for the NPP. I'm eager to dig into the details of that one, and I'll be interested to hear responses from NPP advocates."


Read the rest of the article here.